The New Orleans Saints have faced ongoing struggles this season, and for many fans and analysts, the question has become not if but why. Despite having a talented roster, particularly with players like Derek Carr and Alvin Kamara, the Saints have repeatedly fallen short, sparking a search for answers. With each disappointing performance, more people are pointing to head coach Dennis Allen as the issue, arguing that his leadership and decision-making are holding the team back. For many, the case is closed: Dennis Allen is the problem.

Allen, who took over as head coach in 2022 after Sean Payton’s departure, had high expectations on his shoulders. Having served as the Saints’ defensive coordinator for several years, he was familiar with the organization, players, and culture, making him a logical choice for the head role. However, the transition from coordinator to head coach is a challenging one, and Allen has struggled to adapt, especially when it comes to offense and overall team management. Critics argue that Allen’s defensive-minded approach lacks the balance needed to maximize the team’s potential, particularly in a league where high-powered offenses have become the key to success.

One key area where Allen’s leadership has come into question is his handling of the offense. Though Carr, the team’s new quarterback, has shown flashes of his abilities, he hasn’t been able to consistently elevate the team. Some blame a lack of cohesion and clear strategy, which ultimately comes back to Allen’s overall leadership. Unlike Payton, who was known for his innovative offensive schemes, Allen’s approach has appeared conservative, sometimes even stagnant. This conservative strategy has led to missed scoring opportunities and a lack of rhythm on the field, frustrating fans and players alike.

Furthermore, some argue that Allen’s game management has been problematic. From questionable play-calling to a lack of effective in-game adjustments, Allen’s decisions have sometimes hindered the Saints rather than helped. In critical moments, the team has appeared unprepared or out of sync, an issue that can often be traced back to coaching. Even the defense, which was once the highlight of Allen’s contributions as a coordinator, hasn’t performed at the elite level many expected under his leadership.

As the losses continue to pile up, the call for accountability grows louder. For Saints fans, the patience for Allen’s leadership is wearing thin, and many are pushing for a change before the season slips completely out of reach. The Saints have a roster capable of success, but without the right leadership, that potential remains untapped. Dennis Allen may have been a solid defensive coordinator, but his effectiveness as a head coach is now in serious doubt. With every game, the evidence seems to mount: Dennis Allen is the issue, and for many, the case is indeed closed.