In what is being described as one of the most shocking managerial shake-ups in recent MLB history, the New York Mets have officially announced the hiring of the New York Yankees’ now-former manager on a two-year contract. This unprecedented cross-town move has not only stunned fans from both boroughs but also sent shockwaves throughout the baseball world.
The announcement came early Monday morning, as the Mets issued a press release confirming the hiring of the longtime Yankees skipper as their new manager — a position that had been vacant following the dismissal of Carlos Mendoza earlier this season.
“We’re thrilled to welcome one of the most respected minds in baseball to lead the Mets into our next chapter,” said Mets President of Baseball Operations David Stearns. “His resume speaks for itself, and we believe his leadership, experience, and knowledge of New York baseball are exactly what this team needs.”
While the Yankees have not yet released a formal statement, sources within the organization say ownership and front office members were “blindsided” by the news.
A Move No One Saw Coming
The move is especially jarring given the long-standing rivalry between the Yankees and Mets — two franchises that, while sharing the same city, have distinctly different histories, fanbases, and front office philosophies.
It’s rare enough for players to switch between the two clubs. A manager making that leap — especially someone still under contract just weeks ago — is practically unheard of.
“This is baseball’s version of a defection,” said MLB analyst Ken Rosenthal. “We’ve never seen something quite like this in modern history. It’s bold. It’s controversial. And it’s going to make this city’s baseball summer absolutely electric.”
The terms of the contract are reported to include a 2-year deal worth approximately $9.5 million, with performance bonuses tied to postseason appearances. The contract also reportedly gives the new Mets skipper increased control over team strategy and input on roster decisions — something he may have lacked in the Yankees’ rigid organizational structure.
Why the Move? Frustration Behind the Scenes
According to sources close to the situation, tensions had been mounting behind the scenes between the former Yankees manager and team executives. Despite leading the team to consistent playoff berths, he was often criticized for lineup decisions and his handling of the pitching staff.
“There was a feeling that he was being micromanaged,” one source said. “He wanted more autonomy. The Mets offered him that — and the chance to build something from the ground up.”
It’s also believed that the Yankees’ lack of clarity regarding his long-term future played a role. As his previous contract neared its final year, the team had not committed to an extension, leading to speculation about a possible exit.
Fan Reactions: Yankees Stunned, Mets Energized
The news sparked immediate and fierce reactions from both fanbases. Yankees fans took to social media in disbelief, with many calling the move a “betrayal.”
“First we lose our manager, now we have to watch him in blue and orange? This is surreal,” tweeted one longtime Yankees season ticket holder.
Mets fans, on the other hand, erupted with excitement — and a bit of playful gloating.
“We just stole the Yankees’ braintrust. Let’s gooooo!” posted one Mets fan account.
The Mets are currently in a rebuilding phase but have a promising young core and an aggressive ownership group led by billionaire Steve Cohen. The hiring of a high-profile manager sends a clear message: they are serious about returning to postseason contention — and they’re not afraid to shake things up to get there.
What’s Next for the Yankees?
The Yankees now face the daunting task of replacing one of the longest-tenured and most recognizable managers in franchise history. While names like Don Mattingly, Buck Showalter, and Carlos Beltrán have already surfaced in early speculation, the Yankees’ front office will likely conduct a thorough search.
“They’ll need someone who understands the weight of the pinstripes, but also someone who can navigate a modern clubhouse,” said YES Network analyst Jack Curry. “It won’t be easy.”
A New Era in New York Baseball
As the 2025 season marches on, this managerial bombshell adds even more fuel to the fiery rivalry between the Yankees and Mets. The Subway Series, already one of the most anticipated matchups in baseball, will now come with an added layer of intrigue — the manager who switched sides in the most dramatic way possible.
This isn’t just a managerial change — it’s a seismic shift in New York baseball.
And as both teams adjust to their new realities, fans across the city are left wondering what could come next in one of the wildest seasons in recent memory.