St Louis Cardinals owner William Dewitt Jr makes a shocking Report to MLB about the head coach Olive Marmol why… see more
St. Louis Cardinals Owner William DeWitt Jr. Makes Shocking Report to MLB About Head Coach Oli Marmol – Organization in Turmoil
St. Louis, MO – In a move that has stunned fans, media, and insiders across Major League Baseball, St. Louis Cardinals owner William DeWitt Jr. has reportedly filed a confidential report to MLB officials regarding concerns tied to current manager Oliver “Oli” Marmol, triggering widespread speculation and uncertainty within the organization.
Multiple league sources confirmed late Thursday that DeWitt personally reached out to MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred with what is being described as a “serious organizational matter” involving Marmol’s conduct, leadership decisions, and his recent handling of internal team affairs.
A Shocking Development in St. Louis
The Cardinals, one of MLB’s most storied franchises, have experienced mounting pressure this season after a disappointing 2024 campaign and a slow start to 2025. Tensions have reportedly been growing behind the scenes between front office executives and Marmol, who was retained despite a sub-.500 record last season.
The nature of DeWitt’s report has not been officially disclosed, but league insiders suggest it involves a combination of team management concerns, communication breakdowns with players, and possible violations of internal protocols that reached a level DeWitt could no longer overlook.
One source close to the situation said, “This isn’t a routine performance evaluation — it’s deeper. DeWitt felt he had no choice but to bring this to the league’s attention before things escalated further.”
Oli Marmol Under Fire
Marmol, who became the youngest MLB manager in 2022, initially gained praise for his bold approach and analytical mindset. However, over the past year, his relationship with several players — particularly veterans — has soured, with reports of heated disagreements, clubhouse tension, and inconsistent lineups that have drawn criticism from fans and analysts alike.
Last month, Marmol made headlines after benching a star player mid-game without explanation, which some insiders say contributed to a growing divide between him and team leadership. While the Cardinals front office remained silent on the matter at the time, it now appears to have been a tipping point.
Players Caught Off Guard
Following the leak of DeWitt’s report to MLB, players were seen leaving Thursday’s practice in silence, with several declining to speak to reporters.
However, one veteran player, speaking anonymously, said: “We all feel the pressure, but it’s been tense in that clubhouse for a while now. Something had to give.”
Others expressed concern about the distraction this could bring to an already struggling team.
“It’s hard enough to win games right now. Now we’ve got to deal with this bombshell? It’s just tough,” another player added.
What Happens Next?
As of Friday morning, MLB had not released an official statement, but sources say the league is conducting a quiet inquiry into the matter. If Marmol is found to have violated any league or team conduct rules, disciplinary action could range from a fine to a suspension — or even dismissal.
Meanwhile, the Cardinals organization has declined to comment officially, though a brief internal memo circulated among staff confirmed that “the front office is working closely with league officials and will provide updates when appropriate.”
Fans have already begun speculating about possible replacements should the Cardinals decide to part ways with Marmol. Among the rumored candidates are bench coach Joe McEwing and former Cardinals catcher and fan-favorite Yadier Molina, who has expressed interest in a future managerial role.
DeWitt’s Legacy at Stake?
William DeWitt Jr., who has owned the Cardinals since 1995, is known for keeping a relatively low profile and rarely interferes in day-to-day management unless absolutely necessary. The fact that he would bypass his front office and bring concerns directly to MLB suggests the severity of the issue.
Baseball columnist Ken Rosenthal noted, “DeWitt making a move like this tells you everything. He’s not one to act impulsively. There’s likely more going on behind the scenes than we know.”
Fan Reactions Mixed
Cardinals fans, passionate and loyal, reacted swiftly online. Some expressed frustration over yet another season marred by internal drama, while others praised DeWitt for taking action.
“It’s about time someone held Marmol accountable. We’ve been watching the team spiral,” wrote one fan on Twitter.
Others, however, urged patience.
“Let’s not jump to conclusions. We need all the facts before we throw the manager under the bus,” another fan tweeted.
The Road Ahead
With the Cardinals sitting near the bottom of the NL Central and struggling to find rhythm both offensively and defensively, the timing of this revelation adds another layer of difficulty to an already rocky start to the season.
For now, all eyes are on MLB and the Cardinals front office as they navigate what could be a pivotal moment in the franchise’s modern history.
One thing is clear: the report filed by William DeWitt Jr. has put the spotlight on Oli Marmol like never before — and the future of the Cardinals’ leadership hangs in the balance.