From Star to bust Yankees Considering Cutting Ties With Star Reliever Devin Williams in Shocking deadline move…
Yankees Consider Parting Ways with Star Reliever Devin Williams Amidst Struggles
The New York Yankees are reportedly contemplating severing ties with star reliever Devin Williams before the upcoming trade deadline, a move that would mark a dramatic turn for a pitcher once regarded as one of the game’s elite bullpen arms.
A Promising Acquisition Turns Sour
In December 2024, the Yankees acquired Williams from the Milwaukee Brewers in exchange for left-hander Nestor Cortés, infielder Caleb Durbin, and cash considerations. At the time, Williams was coming off a stellar 2024 season in which he posted a 1.25 ERA with 14 saves in 22 games, despite a back injury that limited his appearances. His devastating “Airbender” changeup and high strikeout rate made him a coveted asset for New York’s bullpen.
Early Season Struggles
However, Williams’ transition to the Bronx has been far from smooth. Through 15 appearances in 2025, he has posted a concerning 9.24 ERA, a stark contrast to his previous dominance. His strikeout rate has plummeted to 18.2%, and his once-feared changeup has become less effective, ranking below average in run value according to Statcast metrics.
These struggles have led to a reassessment of his role within the team. Manager Aaron Boone has removed Williams from the closer position, opting instead for Luke Weaver, who has excelled in the high-leverage role.
Trade Value in Question
The Yankees’ front office now faces a dilemma: whether to attempt to trade Williams before the deadline or to cut their losses and release him. However, the trade market for Williams appears limited. A recent poll of MLB executives revealed that half believe Williams is currently “untradeable” due to his underperformance and expiring contract.
Even if a trade were possible, the Yankees would likely not recover the value they invested in the deal. Cortés has been sidelined with a flexor strain, and Durbin has just made his Major League debut, making the trade appear less favorable for New York
Looking Ahead
With the trade deadline approaching, the Yankees must decide whether to continue investing in Williams’ potential or to part ways and seek alternative bullpen options. The team’s performance in the coming weeks may influence this decision, as they aim to strengthen their bullpen for a postseason push.
For now, Williams’ future with the Yankees remains uncertain, and his once-promising tenure in New York hangs in the balance.