In a stunning development that has sent waves of surprise through LSU Tigers fans and the college football world, head coach Brian Kelly made a shocking announcement on Thursday morning: sophomore Garrett Nussmeier has officially been named the starting quarterback for the 2025 season. This decision has sent shockwaves through Baton Rouge and beyond, particularly since many fans and analysts had assumed that junior Jayden Daniels would retain the starting role after a stellar 2024 season.
In his press conference, Coach Kelly confirmed the decision that many didn’t see coming, especially considering Daniels’ success last year, which included leading LSU to a New Year’s Six bowl appearance. However, Kelly explained that the decision was not taken lightly, emphasizing that Nussmeier had earned the starting role based on his performances in spring practices and his continued development within the team.
Kelly’s Announcement
The moment Coach Brian Kelly stepped up to the podium in Baton Rouge on Thursday, the atmosphere was electric with anticipation. Fans and media alike had been waiting for an official announcement on the quarterback competition, which had intensified over the last few months. What they didn’t expect was the news that Nussmeier — not Daniels — would be the one to lead LSU into the 2025 season.
“After careful evaluation of both Garrett and Jayden, we’ve made the decision to name Garrett Nussmeier our starting quarterback for the 2025 season,” Kelly said, his tone firm yet respectful. “This decision was made based on his consistency, his leadership, and his growth throughout the spring. Garrett has shown time and again that he has the tools to lead this team to victory, and we believe he’s ready to take the next step as our starting quarterback.”
Kelly continued to emphasize the growth of both quarterbacks but stated that Nussmeier’s ability to execute the game plan and make key plays under pressure ultimately gave him the edge.
“This was not an easy decision. Jayden is a tremendous talent, and he will continue to be an integral part of our offense moving forward. But Garrett has stepped up, and he’s proven he can handle the responsibility of being the leader of this team. We’re excited to see what he can do.”
The Shock and Reactions From Fans
The announcement immediately triggered a wave of shock and mixed emotions from LSU fans across the country. Nussmeier’s rise to the starting role had been discussed quietly in certain circles, but the majority of fans had expected Daniels to continue as the starting quarterback given his strong performance in 2024.
“I honestly can’t believe it,” said LSU fan Marcus Jenkins, who’s followed the team for over 30 years. “Jayden Daniels was incredible last season. He was the reason we had such a strong finish. Nussmeier’s talented, but it’s a huge leap to go with him as the starter over Daniels.”
Many fans echoed this sentiment on social media, expressing their surprise and confusion over Kelly’s decision. However, there were also plenty of fans who saw Nussmeier’s potential and praised Kelly for his bold move.
“I think this is a big move for the future of the team,” said LSU supporter Julia Thomas. “Nussmeier has a cannon for an arm, and his ceiling is sky-high. Maybe this is about looking ahead to the next few years, not just one season.”
On Twitter, the reactions were a blend of shock and anticipation:
-
“I’m shocked, but I trust Coach Kelly. If Garrett’s the guy, he’s the guy. #GeauxTigers”
-
“Huge decision. Nussmeier is talented, but this is a lot of pressure. Hope he’s ready.”
-
“Can’t believe it. Jayden Daniels deserves to start, but I’ll back Coach Kelly. Let’s see what happens.”
What Led to Nussmeier’s Rise?
The move to give Nussmeier the starting role, while surprising, is not entirely without merit. In fact, the sophomore quarterback had been a rising star throughout LSU’s spring practices and summer workouts, impressing coaches and teammates with his maturity, leadership, and raw talent.
Garrett Nussmeier, a former 4-star recruit from Louisiana, had a limited role in the 2024 season, seeing action primarily in mop-up duty and a few key moments in blowouts. However, his performance in those appearances had fans and analysts buzzing. With his strong arm, quick release, and ability to make downfield throws, Nussmeier flashed the kind of talent that many believe could take LSU’s offense to the next level.
During the spring, Nussmeier had one of the most impressive training camp performances in recent memory. Reports from inside the LSU camp indicated that he had made significant strides in terms of decision-making, reading defenses, and overall field awareness. His connection with LSU’s talented receiving corps, including All-SEC wide receiver Malik Nabers, was particularly notable.
In contrast, while Jayden Daniels had an excellent 2024 season, including setting LSU records for total yards and touchdowns, there were still areas of his game that could be improved. Daniels, known for his dual-threat ability and speed, sometimes struggled with consistency in the passing game, particularly in key moments when the Tigers needed to make a big play. While he was electric on the ground, some analysts questioned whether LSU’s offense could reach its full potential with Daniels running the show long-term.
With Nussmeier showing progress in both his physical and mental game, Kelly’s decision seems to have been based on a desire for a more balanced, dynamic passing attack that can complement LSU’s already powerful rushing game.
The Future of Jayden Daniels
While Nussmeier is now LSU’s starting quarterback, Coach Kelly made it clear that Daniels still has a significant role to play in the Tigers’ offensive scheme. Despite losing out on the starting role, Daniels will remain a key figure in the team’s plans, potentially taking on a hybrid role or contributing in different ways as a backup.
Kelly acknowledged Daniels’ skill set and leadership in his press conference:
“Jayden has been nothing short of phenomenal for us. His leadership and ability to perform in big moments are invaluable. He’s an important part of our team, and we’ll continue to find ways to get him involved in our offense.”
Many fans are hopeful that Daniels will remain a key contributor for LSU, whether as a backup quarterback or in a more creative offensive role. Given his speed and playmaking ability, Daniels could still see significant playing time in certain situations, such as short-yardage situations or special packages designed to exploit his athleticism.
What This Means for LSU’s 2025 Season
With Nussmeier now set to lead the team, LSU’s 2025 season is expected to be one of high expectations. The Tigers are coming off a successful 2024 campaign, and with Nussmeier at the helm, they will be looking to make a deep run in the SEC and beyond.
The Tigers’ offensive scheme will likely be adjusted to highlight Nussmeier’s strengths. With a strong arm and deep-ball accuracy, LSU may look to open up the playbook and stretch the field more, taking full advantage of their talented receiving corps. Additionally, LSU’s stellar offensive line and strong running game will give Nussmeier the time and support he needs to succeed.
Defensively, LSU is stacked with talent, and the team’s focus will now shift toward ensuring that the offense, led by Nussmeier, can consistently put up points against some of the toughest competition in the nation.
The SEC West remains one of the most competitive divisions in college football, and LSU’s performance in 2025 will be closely watched. Nussmeier’s success — or struggles — could be the deciding factor in whether the Tigers can contend for an SEC title and make a push for the College Football Playoff.
What’s Next for LSU?
As LSU moves forward with Garrett Nussmeier as their starting quarterback, the focus will now turn to building chemistry between him and his teammates. LSU’s coaching staff will work to develop a game plan that plays to Nussmeier’s strengths, while also providing Daniels with opportunities to contribute in creative ways.
For now, all eyes are on the 2025 season, and with a talented team surrounding Nussmeier, LSU has the potential to be one of the most dangerous teams in the nation.
Final Thoughts
Coach Brian Kelly’s surprising announcement that Garrett Nussmeier has been named LSU’s starting quarterback for the 2025 season has shaken up the Tigers’ quarterback battle in a major way. Fans were caught off guard, but Coach Kelly’s confidence in Nussmeier’s development speaks to the young QB’s potential. As LSU adjusts to this new reality, the upcoming season promises to be filled with excitement, intrigue, and the possibility of a new era for the Tigers.