5 Cardinals Players Most Likely to Be Traded This Offseason

The St. Louis Cardinals are entering a pivotal offseason as they aim to bounce back from a disappointing 2023 campaign. After finishing with one of their worst records in recent memory, the Cardinals are determined to retool their roster, especially their pitching staff, to contend in 2024. To achieve this, they may look to trade some of their players to acquire the necessary assets. Here are five players most likely to be traded this offseason:

1. Tyler O’Neill

Tyler O’Neill has long been a tantalizing mix of power, speed, and Gold Glove defense. However, injuries and inconsistent performance have plagued the outfielder, leaving the Cardinals with questions about his long-term future. At 28, O’Neill still has significant trade value, especially for teams needing a dynamic outfielder. Moving O’Neill could open up opportunities for younger players like Jordan Walker and Lars Nootbaar to solidify their roles in the outfield.

2. Dylan Carlson

Once considered a cornerstone of the Cardinals’ future, Dylan Carlson has struggled to meet expectations. Limited playing time in 2023 and lingering injuries have hindered his development, but his age (25) and potential as a switch-hitter make him an attractive trade chip. Carlson could thrive with a fresh start elsewhere, and the Cardinals might use him to acquire pitching depth or a proven starter.

3. Nolan Gorman

While trading Nolan Gorman might seem surprising given his breakout 2023 season, the Cardinals face a logjam in their infield. Gorman’s power bat could fetch a high return in the trade market, especially from teams seeking a young slugger with team control. If the Cardinals want to land a top-tier starting pitcher, including Gorman in a package deal could make it happen.

4. Tommy Edman

Tommy Edman’s versatility and elite defense make him a valuable player for any team. The 28-year-old has been a consistent contributor for the Cardinals, but with top prospect Masyn Winn ready to take over at shortstop, Edman could become expendable. His ability to play multiple positions and his reasonable contract would appeal to contenders looking to fill gaps in their roster.

5. Jack Flaherty (or a similar arm)

Although Flaherty signed with another team after the 2023 season, the Cardinals’ pattern of trading arms in their contract year remains relevant. Another pitcher in a similar situation, such as Dakota Hudson or Matthew Liberatore, could be on the move if the Cardinals decide to retool their rotation. Given their focus on upgrading their pitching, dealing from their existing pool of arms to acquire established talent seems likely.

Why Trades Are Essential

The Cardinals’ front office has already signaled its intent to prioritize pitching this offseason, especially after falling short in 2023. Acquiring starting pitchers like Aaron Nola and Sonny Gray is a step in the right direction, but the team may not stop there. Trading surplus talent, particularly in the outfield and infield, could help the Cardinals land another ace or bullpen depth.

With a strong farm system and several young players ready to make an impact, the Cardinals are well-positioned to make strategic moves. If executed correctly, these trades could help St. Louis return to contention in 2024 and beyond.

As the offseason progresses, these five players will be names to watch on the trade market. Whether the Cardinals pull off blockbuster deals or smaller moves to fine-tune their roster, the upcoming months will shape the team’s direction for years to come.