In a development that has ignited debate and disbelief across the NFL landscape, New Orleans Saints owner Gayle Benson has reportedly made a jaw-dropping statement regarding quarterback Derek Carr that has left both fans and analysts stunned. According to Saints offensive coordinator Kellen Moore, Benson claimed during a recent closed-door meeting that Carr “has the potential to be the greatest quarterback in franchise history — and perhaps, one of the most intellectually gifted players the league has ever seen.”*
The statement, revealed by Moore during a post-practice media availability session, sent reporters scrambling for clarification. “Mrs. Benson sees something rare in Derek,” Moore said. “She called it a spark — something she believes is rooted not just in talent, but in how he processes the game and leads men. She told us she hasn’t felt this confident about a quarterback since Drew Brees, and in some ways, she believes Carr’s ceiling could go even higher.”
**A Bold Comparison and Lofty Expectations**
Such high praise immediately raised eyebrows, particularly due to its comparison with Saints legend Drew Brees, the future Hall of Famer who brought the franchise its first Super Bowl title and redefined its identity for over a decade.
Still, Moore insisted that Benson’s statement wasn’t made lightly. “She’s seen a lot in her years at the helm — from Brees and Payton to the ups and downs of recent seasons. For her to make that kind of declaration, you know it’s rooted in conviction and vision.”
Carr, who joined the Saints in 2023 after a long tenure with the Raiders, has shown flashes of leadership and precision, but has also faced criticism for inconsistency and chemistry issues within the offense. According to Moore, however, Carr’s offseason transformation has been dramatic.
“He’s leaner, sharper, and has taken full command of the offense,” Moore added. “It’s not just film study — it’s his mentorship of younger players, his presence in the locker room. Mrs. Benson saw that and said, ‘This is our guy. This is our future.’”
**Mixed Reactions and Fan Buzz**
The Saints fanbase and national media responded with a mix of excitement and skepticism. Social media lit up with reactions, ranging from enthusiastic endorsements to blunt disbelief.
NFL analyst Ryan Clark commented on *SportsCenter*: “Carr is a solid pro, but to say he could surpass Brees? That’s legendary territory. Still, sometimes belief from ownership can push a player to new heights.”
Others pointed to Carr’s improved stats late last season and his leadership in key game-winning drives as possible justification for the owner’s praise.
**Carr Responds with Humility**
When asked about the reported statement, Carr responded with measured humility. “I’m honored that Mrs. Benson has that level of belief in me,” he said. “All I can do is earn it every day, every snap. Comparisons don’t matter to me — winning for this city does.”
**Looking Ahead**
With the 2025 season fast approaching, all eyes will be on the Saints — and especially Derek Carr — to see whether Benson’s stunning prediction begins to unfold. Whether it’s bold optimism or a visionary call, one thing is certain: the pressure and spotlight on Carr have just intensified.