BYU Cougars Lock In Star Quarterback McCae Hillstead’s Transfer as Kalani Sitake Strengthens 2025 Roster and..
In a significant move that’s already sending shockwaves through the college football landscape, McCae Hillstead, the dynamic young quarterback formerly at Utah State, has officially transferred to BYU, giving Head Coach Kalani Sitake a high-upside signal-caller to lead the Cougars into a new era of Big 12 competition.
Hillstead, a former standout at Skyridge High School in Lehi, Utah, made headlines during his freshman campaign at Utah State with his quick release, impressive pocket presence, and dual-threat capabilities. Despite battling injuries and a quarterback rotation, Hillstead showed flashes of elite potential—something BYU fans are now buzzing about as he makes the jump to LaVell Edwards Stadium.
“McCae brings energy, leadership, and a serious edge to our quarterback room,” Sitake said in a statement. “He’s tough, smart, and he fits the culture we’re building here at BYU.”
With the Cougars looking to bounce back from a challenging 2024 season and reassert themselves in the Big 12, Hillstead’s arrival could be a turning point. The move also continues a trend of Sitake and offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick targeting proven in-state talent and utilizing the transfer portal to reload rather than rebuild.
Sources close to the program say Hillstead is already connecting with teammates and is expected to compete for the starting role immediately, potentially sparking one of the most anticipated quarterback battles in recent BYU history.
Fans, alumni, and analysts alike are taking notice—BYU isn’t just preparing for next season; it’s positioning itself for a serious climb in the conference standings and a possible return to national relevance.