BYU Cougars QB McCae Hillstead Poised to Lead BYU Cougars’ Charge in Crucial 2025 Big 12 Season and..

As the BYU Cougars prepare to embark on their second full season in the Big 12 Conference, all eyes are on quarterback McCae Hillstead — a talented transfer with something to prove and the tools to deliver.

After arriving in Provo with a chip on his shoulder and a cannon for an arm, Hillstead has quickly established himself as one of the most intriguing players on the Cougars’ 2025 roster. Known for his poise under pressure, quick release, and dual-threat capabilities, the sophomore signal-caller is expected to compete for — and potentially secure — the starting job this fall.

“McCae brings a different level of energy and leadership to the offense,” said offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick. “He’s young, but he’s confident. He plays like someone who’s been in big games before, and we believe he’s ready to take that next step.”

Hillstead’s arrival comes at a critical time for BYU. After a rollercoaster 2024 campaign that saw flashes of potential but ultimately fell short of postseason goals, the Cougars are looking to reassert themselves in a competitive Big 12 landscape. With Hillstead at the helm, the offense could see a major spark.

Veteran teammates have taken notice of Hillstead’s work ethic and composure. “He’s in the film room all the time,” said senior wide receiver Kody Epps. “He wants to get it right. You can see the chemistry starting to build already.”

The 2025 schedule offers no breaks — road matchups against Texas Tech and Kansas State, plus a home showdown with Utah, loom large. But BYU fans are hopeful that Hillstead can be the steady hand needed to guide the Cougars back into the national conversation.

Whether he earns the QB1 spot or continues to grow as part of a deep quarterback room, one thing is clear: McCae Hillstead isn’t just a future name to watch — he’s ready to make an impact now.